The Campus Culture Problem

The Campus Culture Problem
Why your college keeps doing what isn’t working
Robin Capehart

Nov 9

“We’ve always done it this way.”

If you’ve spent any time on a college campus, you’ve heard it. Maybe in a faculty meeting. Maybe in a budget hearing. Maybe at the board table. And if you’re honest, you may have said it yourself. I know I have.

After fourteen years as a college president, and the years since advising colleges that are struggling, here’s what I’ve learned: most colleges don’t keep doing what isn’t working because their leaders are lazy or careless. They keep doing it because of something much harder to see. They are following popular thinking.

Enrollment drops, so we add a program. Enrollment drops again, so we add a sport. Then we spend more on marketing, discount tuition a little deeper and build a nicer residence hall. Every college around us is doing the same thing, so it must be right.

It feels like leadership. Too often, it’s just following the crowd.

The Problem With Popular Thinking
John Maxwell, one of the best-known writers on leadership, counts knowing when to question popular thinking among the skills that set successful thinkers apart. It’s a skill college leaders badly need.

Popular thinking is simply what everyone else is doing. It’s appealing for good reasons. It feels safe: nobody gets fired for doing what every other college is doing. It comes with ready-made proof: the college down the road added athletics, and their numbers went up. And it spares us the hard work of thinking for ourselves.

But popular thinking has a flaw. It tells you what is common, not what is right. When every college chases the same students with the same tools, the tools stop working. Discounts get deeper. Programs multiply. Marketing budgets grow. And the results keep shrinking.

I want to be fair here. Some of those moves can work as near-term fixes. I used several of them myself, and they helped. A new program can bring in students. A marketing push can turn a bad year around. The trouble starts when the near-term fix becomes the plan, and nobody goes back to ask what the college is actually for.

That’s when popular thinking stops being a decision and starts becoming a habit.

From Thinking to Habit to Tradition
Here’s how it happens on campus.

It starts as popular thinking: an idea most people accept without much question. “More programs will fix enrollment.”

Then it becomes a habit. We act on the idea year after year. Every budget cycle brings a new program proposal, and nobody stops to ask whether the last one met a real need.

Then the habit becomes a tradition. It’s no longer an idea at all. It’s simply “the way we do things here.” New faculty and staff learn it the way you learn the rules of a house you’ve just moved into.

And traditions resist change. Once an idea has hardened into tradition, questioning it feels like an attack on the institution itself. People don’t hear “Let’s rethink how we decide on programs.” They hear “You’ve been doing it wrong for twenty years.”

That’s why so many well-meaning change efforts stall. The leader thinks he’s arguing with a bad idea. In reality, he’s arguing with a tradition built on one.

I learned that the hard way. I could change what a college did much faster than I could change what it believed. The near-term fixes came quickly. The culture change came slowly, and where the culture didn’t change, the gains didn’t last.

You can’t knock down a tradition head-on. You have to go underneath it, to the thinking it was built on, and replace that thinking with something stronger.

That something is principle.

The Lighthouse and the Fog
Stephen Covey drew a line every college leader should know: the difference between principles and values.

Values are what we choose to care about. They can be good or bad, and they can drift with the times. Principles are different. Covey described them as guidelines for human conduct “proven to have enduring, permanent value.” They work like natural laws. They hold whether we accept them or not.

Covey liked to tell an old story about a battleship captain in the fog. A light appears ahead, and the captain signals the other vessel to change course. The reply comes back: you change course. Offended, the captain announces that he is a battleship. The answer: “I’m a lighthouse.”

The point, as Covey put it, is that you don’t break principles. You only break yourself against them.

Popular thinking is the fog. It shifts with every budget cycle and every new trend. Principles are the lighthouse. They don’t move.

Here’s the irony. Popular thinking changes with fashion, yet it hardens into tradition and traps us. Principles never change, yet they’re what free an institution to change.

At a college, I’d name three. Growth: adding real value to the student, the institution and the community. Integrity: a diploma is a promise that the graduate is prepared, and that promise has to be true. Responsibility: a duty to prepare students for the working world and to send the community graduates who are ready.

When our values rest on principles like those, they stop drifting.

What a Leader Does About It
So what does a leader do? I mean leader broadly. John Maxwell defines leadership as influence, nothing more and nothing less. If you have influence at a college, whether from the president’s office, the board table, a department or an advising desk, this is your job too.

First, name the popular thinking. Ask “Why do we do it this way?” and keep asking until you reach the idea underneath the habit.

Second, test it against principle. Does this add value for students and the community? Does it keep the diploma’s promise true? Does it meet our duty to send out graduates who are ready?

Third, begin with why before you decide what. A college that knows its purpose, meeting the needs of its community, has a way to judge every new program, sport and marketing campaign. Some will pass the test. Many won’t.

None of this happens in a single meeting. Culture is how people think, act and interact, and it changes only when what people value changes. But it starts with one leader willing to question popular thinking out loud.

The next time someone says, “We’ve always done it this way,” don’t argue with the tradition. Ask about the thinking underneath it. That’s where real change begins.

Robin Capehart served as a university president for fourteen years at two different institutions. Today, he is a nationally recognized speaker, teacher, coach and senior consultant focusing on higher education for Collegiate Consulting.